Mike Maguire

License #: 1587485

4.9 OUT OF 5 STARS

(268 Reviews)

Need help with an existing policy?

Contact My Team

You’re minutes away from the best coverage for your home, car and more.

Get A Quote

About Mike

Mike Maguire is an agent with Goosehead Insurance located in Neptune, NJ. Mike joined Goosehead because of his unwavering commitment to take care of his clients. Using cutting edge technology to shop with dozens of "A" rated insurance companies in just a few short minutes, he is able to find the right coverage at a competitive price. He takes the time to review all of the options and customizes a policy based on the unique risks and desires of each client. After finalizing an option, Mike is backed by a service team that has the highest client loyalty rating in the industry. Request a quote from Mike and you will quickly understand why Goosehead is one of the fastest growing distributors of home and auto insurance in the United States.

States Licensed In: NJ, CT, PA, NY

Connect

3455 Route 66, Suite 3A,
Neptune, NJ 07753

(732) 479-3777

Languages spoken:
English

Hours:

We’ve got you covered,

and then some.

Homeowners Insurance >
Auto Insurance >
Flood Insurance >
Renters Insurance >
Condo Insurance >
Landlord Insurance >
Motorcycle Insurance >
Boat Insurance >
RV Insurance >
Life Insurance >

You probably looked at several houses before you found the right fit; why not look at home insurance the same way? Goosehead does the looking for you, and finds the policy that fits your needs and budget, without compromising coverage.

Get a Quote

It seems like there’s as many car insurance companies out there as there are cars. Lucky for you, Goosehead looks under the hood of all those policies to find the right coverage for you and your ride. Think of us as your roadmap to better protection and better rates.

Get a Quote

Having the right amount of protection in case of flooding is important. That’s why our Goosehead experts will do all the research for you. We’ll compare dozens of plans and choose what’s best for your residence, and your budget.

Get a Quote

Sure, you may not own the building. But you own what’s in it. If a fire or disaster would cause a major setback, take a close look at renters insurance. Better yet, let us do it for you. We’ve evaluated products from dozens of the most respected insurance companies to help you home in on the right policy.

Get a Quote

From an insurance standpoint, high rises, townhomes and condos can be, well, a little different. HOAs cover some parts of the property, leaving other areas up to you. We can help you find a policy that provides the coverage you need — at rates you’ll feel right at home with.

Get a Quote

A rental property isn’t the same as a primary residence. Without proper protection, a landlord might be personally liable for damages from accidents or other events. We can help you determine the right coverage for your rental properties and compare rental property insurance quotes so you can operate with total peace of mind.

Get a Quote

Driving a motorcycle is all about freedom. Speaking of freedom, there’s no need for you to spend end less hours of your free time comparing insurance plans. Comparing the best motorcycle policies from the best insurance companies to get you protected the way you should be protected, at the price you deserve.

Get a Quote

Chances are you bought a boat for a little rest and relaxation. Goosehead makes shopping for boat insurance just as relaxing. Our expert agents will shop dozens of policies and find you the right protection, at the right price, that will really float your boat.

Get a Quote

Your RV lets you escape to the open road. And with Goosehead, you can escape the usual time commitment of buying insurance. Our expert agents do the research for you, comparing dozens of policies and choosing the right protection for you and your home on wheels, all at the price you deserve.

Get a Quote

As the saying goes, life happens. But sometimes it happens in ways we don’t expect. For all the great times, and the more difficult times, Goosehead can be there to make sure you and your family are prepared, and protected. If something happens to you, the right coverage will ensure your family is financially secure and well taken care of in your absence.

Get a Quote

HOMEOWNER INSURANCE

Water Coverages Explained

Four different types of water coverage may or may not be part of your home insurance policy. Let’s look at how they could help better protect you and your family from financial burden due to various causes of water damage to your home.

Recent Reviews

Total Agency Reviews 268

Benjamin C., Nov, 04 2024

He took care of our insurance need’s promptly.

Joann N., Nov, 01 2024

Made shopping for insurance easy. Best rates found.

Robert F., Nov, 01 2024

Customer service

Daniel C., Oct, 16 2024

Michael did a great job finding me savings for home and auto insurance

Kat M., Oct, 07 2024

Mike was incredibly responsive, kind, understanding, thorough, and helped us secure the best plan for our home insurance needs on the very same day that we reached out to him. Mike was highly recommended to us and we will certainly be recommending him to family and friends. Thanks Mike!

Aaron E., Oct, 03 2024

Excellent communication, follow-up and details! Thanks for being straight forward and direct.

Frank G., Oct, 03 2024

Instead of just getting a quote on line I was able to speak to someone and get explanation for item on the policy. Very valuable.

Subodh N., Sep, 30 2024

Excellent service by Mike. Very responsive and thorough

Melanie L., Sep, 24 2024

Mike was very responsive and quick to act. Very accomodating

Craig E., Sep, 21 2024

Excellent customer service

Charles S., Sep, 21 2024

Great service

Chee C., Sep, 21 2024

Mike is very efficient in finding a good policy with reasonable premium costs. He is very polite and professional.

Alice L., Sep, 20 2024

Mike was fantastic. Informative, reassuring, answered every question I had and even some I didn't think of. He even helped me with suggestions regarding other insurance policies I have that were extremely beneficial! Very very happy. No complaints at all.

Sarah I., Sep, 20 2024

Everything was crazy easy and came out cheaper than others!

Shawn A., Sep, 19 2024

Excellent customer service

Fung C., Sep, 18 2024

Mike Maguire has been very helpful in finding a Home Owner Insurance policy that suits my needs promptly. He is very polite and professional.

Dominyka S., Sep, 17 2024

Mike was able to put together a better policy that protects us better for a lower price than any other quote we got from anyone else for our home insurance. He was super knowledgeable and nice! 10/10 would recommend!

Kolleen S., Sep, 15 2024

Mike was so helpful in the insurance process. He walked us through every step and made us feel comfortable with our decisions.

Christopher B., Sep, 15 2024

Mike Maguire couldn't have been nicer: down to earth, very knowledgable, easy to talk to, and answered every single one of our very many questions regarding the changes we wanted to make not only in our policy but in the carrier as well. Mike made the whole process very streamlined and pain free.

Amy A., Sep, 12 2024

Mike is great! He explained everything in detail so I understood everything about the insurance we picked.

Serafima K., Sep, 11 2024

Mike was awesome, answered all of my questions and helped me immensely.

THE C., Sep, 08 2024

The reason is Mike Maguire. I work in the Real Estate Title Industry and as with all insurance, you get what you get, but how I'm treated is what makes my decisions and Mike jumped in when I needed him; understood what had to be done and with the upmost courtesy, did it!!

Emilio A., Aug, 23 2024

Mike Maguire was fantastic. He helped me get 2 distinct policies together in less than 24hrs. He was referred to me by a friend, and I'm glad they referred him. 10/10

Michael A., Aug, 19 2024

Mike was great!

Robin S., Aug, 17 2024

Mike was very thorough, explained everything, and found the best option for my needs.

Mark M., Aug, 16 2024

I was given a very high premium from another company. I'm really glad I was able to connect with Mike on this. He was able to give me a reasonable premium and go through the entire coverage with me. This is definitely a service that is worth recommending to others.

Susan G., Aug, 15 2024

I was referred to Mike Maguire after having a bad experience with an insurance company where my insurance doubled. I was very upset and one call to Mike was all I needed. He was so easy to talk with, very knowledgeable and caring about my issue. He helped me lower my costs and made the whole process of signing document super easy. I can't thank Mike enough. I have already been telling everyone I know about Goosehead Insurance. Thank you to Mike Maguire and Goosehead Insurance!!!!!!

Sean M., Aug, 14 2024

Mike Maguire was extremely helpful. This was my first time needing home insurance and Mike went through the quote line by line with me explaining everything and helped me select a good plan.

Monique T., Aug, 14 2024

Mike explain everything very well

Catherine M., Aug, 10 2024

Mike was understanding of my needs and what I was looking for, he was easy to get to and quick with starting our policy after showing us a great quote. I will be referring him to my inlaws

Michael W., Aug, 02 2024

Mike’s great ! Saved me $2500 between my homeowners and car insurance

Kelly M., Jul, 25 2024

Timely response. Very professional & friendly. Down to earth & no judgment around how or why i was seeking new coverage. An all around wonderful experience.

Steven E., Jul, 25 2024

It was a great experience setting up my HOI. Mike was super helpful and personable. He explained everything very well.

Rita R., Jul, 20 2024

Mike was great!

Juliann S., Jul, 19 2024

the representative Mike was very informative, patient and knowledgeable. He was able to find the exact policy to suit my needs as a home owner while staying within my budget. I was very impressed with the service

Tone A., Jul, 09 2024

Excellent service!

Simon K., Jul, 08 2024

The experience I have with Mike and Goosehead is unmatched.

Linda C., Jul, 02 2024

Mike deserves a 10! Knowledgeable, patient and great tone.

Katheryn P., Jul, 01 2024

Mike was extremely helpful and made the process flow thru very smoothly and efficiently. He was great to work with!

Jules L., Jun, 26 2024

Very helpful and efficient in getting us set up with proper new policies

George S., Jun, 20 2024

Very respectful and fair pricing.

Marylin P., Jun, 17 2024

Ben was Very responsive and friendly

Robert J., Jun, 10 2024

Mike was great in setting us up... reaponsive, thorough. DocuSign made things easy.

Dinesh R., Jun, 09 2024

Mike understood my requirements and guided accordingly

Dylan W., Jun, 07 2024

Mike Maguire was very helpful and personable making the process straight forward and easy

Robert P., May, 17 2024

Customer service

Hunter F., May, 17 2024

Mike was awesome

Morgan K., May, 12 2024

Mike was very informative and helpful

Lizsete S., Apr, 14 2024

Jack and Mike were so helpful and helped me find exactly what I needed! Very professional.

Danielle Z., Apr, 11 2024

Great customer service !!

Doreen H., Apr, 11 2024

Mike Maguire was very helpful and efficient.

Jonathan C., Apr, 10 2024

Super fast and easy process

Emilia R., Apr, 03 2024

Mike was very personable and obtained a good quote for my budget with adequate coverage.

Angela R., Mar, 29 2024

Everything was explained clearly and efficiently

Frank R., Mar, 29 2024

The process was easy

Abhiroop K., Mar, 25 2024

Easy to work with Mike Maguire. He explained things well and gave a great deal.

Steven B., Mar, 10 2024

Very professional

Zydre Z., Mar, 08 2024

Very kind and helpful

John T., Mar, 07 2024

Helpful and knowledgeable

Lee I., Mar, 02 2024

My sales rep was very knowledgeable and answered all my questions and made it simple to get the insurance

John M., Feb, 22 2024

Mike was very knowledgeable spent time exploring the best options for our needs. I look forward to working with him again in the future.

Zachary M., Feb, 08 2024

Mike was incredibly knowledgeable, attentive and patient / understanding. He took the time to go above and beyond to understand what I am looking to protect and how to do so. I could not recommend working with Mike more!

Susan D., Jan, 27 2024

Mike communication skills were excellent. He was very attentive to our needs and helped every step of the way. We are most grateful that he took the time to answer each and every question we had. Thanks Mike!

Joseph P., Jan, 20 2024

Mike was amazing . Informative, Patient , not pushy and super easy to speak to and ask questions.

Kiendra M., Jan, 12 2024

Mike was very informative and took his time explaining everything to me.

Andrew M., Jan, 10 2024

Mike Maguire was phenomenal. He was super helpful and was able to answer all my questions. I highly recommend him.

Mark C., Dec, 22 2023

Mike found me decent rates and was very professional. Thank You

George C., Dec, 20 2023

answered all my questions......very polite.....was concerend about getting me the best policy for the money and my needs....dealt with his father who is also a good person....runs in family

Daniela C., Dec, 20 2023

Very quick and easy process and everything was explained in detail. Thank you

Annette H., Dec, 06 2023

A smooth transaction.

Diane S., Dec, 05 2023

Mike Maguire made my insurance shopping easy and stress free. He was professional, polite, and patient. All my questions were answered which made me confident with my final decision. It was a pleasant experience.

Reginald T., Dec, 05 2023

Mike was extremely helpful and made the process smooth, concise and welcoming.

Omar F., Dec, 01 2023

Everything was explained to me on a very nice and easy way to understand

Jacki M., Nov, 30 2023

Mike was very thorough and made it simple and easy for me. He was very kind and helpful!

Joseph L., Nov, 28 2023

Mike was very understanding and patient with me in explaining everything. He also has a great personality and demeanor about him and great listening skills. He should be commended.

Frankie F., Nov, 26 2023

Mike was very helpful, took his time to ensure we understood everything and find us the best deal he could with the best coverage.

Kimberly R., Nov, 11 2023

Mike was very helpful and very knowledgeable!

Lisa R., Nov, 09 2023

Great customer attention!

Sabrina M., Oct, 15 2023

Mike was very thorough and patient. He explained everything in simple terms

John C., Oct, 11 2023

Very helpful

Carolyn C., Oct, 11 2023

Mike Maguire was very helpful

Michael A., Oct, 05 2023

Mike was very informative and addressed all my concerns. The transition to Goosehead was very smooth thanks to Mike.

Robin A., Sep, 21 2023

It was very easy and they were very friendly and helpful

Donna S., Sep, 16 2023

Every thing overall very good experience

Charles A., Sep, 14 2023

Mike was able to quickly solve my problem of getting home owners' insurance for my new home purchase.

Maureen M., Sep, 14 2023

Excellent service

Vincent M., Sep, 14 2023

Excellent service

Wendy W., Sep, 07 2023

Great service and very helpful I have already recommended Mike to friends that need new insurance

Carmelo T., Sep, 03 2023

Explained everything fully and clearly.

Thomas K., Sep, 01 2023

very understanding, and kn

Breanna Z., Aug, 29 2023

Helpful, professional, timely

Zakery G., Aug, 29 2023

Mike was very knowledgeable and helpful through the whole process.

Lisa L., Aug, 21 2023

Mike was very responsive and he answered all of my questions regarding my coverage choices and requirements for my new condo insurance. It was a quick and easy process.

Lyndi L., Aug, 17 2023

Helpful and prompt service. Mike ensured that I had all of my questions answered, explained my policy entirely, saved me money, and helped me through the process of switching my insurance. I was recommended to him by a friend and I am glad that I made the call.

Nicole C., Aug, 14 2023

Mike did an amazing job helping us bundle our car/home insurance. He explained everything in detail, made sure we understood everything, and answered all of our questions. He went above and beyond in helping us with jewelry coverage and an umbrella policy as well. I highly recommend Mike for all of your insurance needs. He saved us money too! Job well done!

Pamela F., Aug, 10 2023

Got me a good discount with my auto and and the information that was provided to me was great.

Kathleen D., Aug, 09 2023

Dealing with Mike MaGuire has been the ultimate customer service.

Sherry Y., Aug, 02 2023

Mike was professional, friendly and extremely knowledgeable. I could not be more pleased with his service. I feel that he made sure that I got the best price and product that he could offer. I plan to recommend him to my friends and family.

Frank N., Aug, 01 2023

The service was great

Thomas C., Jul, 31 2023

Mike Maguire was outstanding in terms of understanding client needs and meeting those needs. I would not hesitate recommending him to anyone who has needs for insurance.

Dan C., Jul, 31 2023

I can't say enough good things about my insurance agent, Mike! He's incredibly knowledgeable and easy to work with, making the whole process a breeze. He quickly and efficiently found me the best price, beating six other quotes. Working with Mike has been a pleasure, and I absolutely recommend him for his exceptional service!

Samantha G., Jul, 29 2023

Mike was very informative and was able to answer all my questions.

Mario C., Jul, 28 2023

Very knowledgeable and good customer service

Stacy S., Jul, 20 2023

Mike was clear on explaining the policy and each section of the policy. I don't know much about this stuff being a first time home buyer so he was considerate and helpful through the entire process.

Barbara Z., Jul, 18 2023

Mike Maguire was very confident in his ability to help me save money and receive more value in terms of my insurance needs. Very knowledgeable, pro active, and professional. I'm very happy with the service Mike provided.

Kelly H., Jul, 18 2023

Extremely helpful and answered all of my questions openly and honestly. Highly recommend!

Kathleen H., Jul, 07 2023

Mike Maguire

Diann B., Jun, 27 2023

Mike Macguire was very helpful, knowedgeable and insightful for our homeowners policy and riders. We are happy with all his help.

Johnny C., Jun, 27 2023

Great service & transparency!!

Christopher H., Jun, 24 2023

Good, fast and friendly service

Michael L., Jun, 22 2023

Very informative and knowledgeable. Mike also completely and thoroughly explained coverage details, what they mean, benefits and potential ramifications of options

Timothy H., Jun, 19 2023

Mike macguire was highly informed and very thorough during our conversation. He found us a great plan for the best price. We are very satisfied with the services he provided.

Jose A., Jun, 17 2023

Mike was really friendly and knowledgeable

Sabrina R., Jun, 09 2023

Michael was very thorough and explained in detail about our policy includes optional items as well.

Michael R., Jun, 09 2023

Mike Maquire was very knowledgeable and went over everything. .

Dorothy F., Jun, 07 2023

Mike Macguire was extremely helpful thru the process. He is a professional and conducts the business of insurance in a confident and concise manner. He guided me through decisions giving me the information do I could be confident with the choices I made. Thank You Mike!

Esmirna E., Jun, 02 2023

Michael was very informative and helpful. Thank you

Kelli D., Jun, 02 2023

Car insurance

Anthony F., Jun, 02 2023

Great Service from Mike.

Stephania P., Jun, 01 2023

Flat out, Mike is a great guy to work with

Giuseppe D., May, 07 2023

Excellent customer service from Mike Maguire!

Robin A., May, 04 2023

Mike McGuire was amazing and was able to get me a great rate for my homeowners insurance.

Parris Y., May, 01 2023

Excellent service, best service I’ve had in a while while dealing with transferring all my car info. I would 100% recommend anyone looking for insurance to Mike.

Janea A., Apr, 27 2023

Mike Maguire gave the utmost detail, support and attention to my boyfriend and I while we were purchasing our HOI. Definitely recommend

Ted L., Apr, 27 2023

Friendly, respectful, mindful, and professional quality are with Mike. He is a great insurance guy who may regret a moment after his sales. You retain and serve the customer. Thanks!

Anthony J., Apr, 25 2023

From my experience working with Mike Maguire.

Catalina G., Apr, 25 2023

Mike was amazing! very information and professional, made the process very easy and most important, we are saving over $1200 in our auto policy

Sumeet D., Apr, 22 2023

Mike has been Very helpful all along. Clarified so many of my queries quite quickly. And he provided the best prices for both auto and renters insurance. Can't beat this price for sure. Would highly recommend Mike and Goosehead for all your insurance needs.

Erwin T., Apr, 22 2023

My Agent mike is very helpful and accomodating. Best of luck!

Can K., Apr, 18 2023

The agent’s approach and his professionalism are the main reasons. He handled the process very well from the beginning to the end.

Alexandra B., Apr, 17 2023

Mike was helpful, quick and professional.

W B., Apr, 15 2023

First time dealing with Goosehead Insurance, first time, dealing with MIKE and it was such a pleasure to deal with him. He was very understanding knew what I was looking for found my options gave them to me, and when I head with it very satisfied.

Erin N., Apr, 01 2023

Mike was quick to help me and took the time to explain my coverage. Very much appreciated his help when I was in a pinch!

Emilia B., Mar, 31 2023

Professionalism. Friendly. Looked for the best available options and explained everything clearly.

Judith S., Mar, 25 2023

Mike Maguire went out of his way to give me the coverage I needed.

Lisa W., Mar, 19 2023

Mike Maguire was very accommodating to our need’s regarding homeowners insurance and car insurance. He made it easy and painless and we appreciate that very much.

Gianna D., Feb, 26 2023

I am new to having my own car insurance and not very knowledgeable on it. Mike made me feel very comfortable and made sure that I knew how everything works and what every single detail meant. He was very personable, and for that reason I will refer Goosehead Insurance to all of my friends and family.

GinaMarie A., Feb, 15 2023

The best!

James A., Feb, 13 2023

Although I had a great experience, I rarely give recommendations.

Andrea C., Feb, 09 2023

Mike was very professional, explained our policy in detail, and answered all of our questions. Everything went smoothly from start to finish.

Wojciech K., Feb, 07 2023

Excellent customer service.

John R., Feb, 06 2023

Mike is a great agent. He followed up through a series of phone tag and stuck with getting multiple policies transitioned

Agnes F., Feb, 04 2023

Great quotes, very competitive. And wonderful customer service from the agent.

Michael B., Feb, 03 2023

Michael was very helpful throughout the whole process and answered his phone every time I had a question regarding my policy.

Kreg B., Feb, 01 2023

Mike Maguire was very helpful with explaining the insurance process to a first time home buyer. He answered all my questions. He provided multiple quotes to fit my needs. Professional, experienced, and friendly. Thanks Mike !

Kristen J., Feb, 01 2023

Mike Maguire was extremely helpful and pleasant to work with.

Maria P., Feb, 01 2023

Customer service. Explaining policies. Paying attention to detail.

Roberta P., Jan, 28 2023

Mike is very informative. He was helpful and explained everything.

Joseph M., Jan, 27 2023

Mike was amazing. Very straightforward, helpful, and got me an amazing rate for my policy.

Marilyn R., Jan, 20 2023

Mike is very professional and helpful.

Benjamin P., Jan, 11 2023

Very fast answer to all our inquiry, good service

Marie P., Dec, 30 2022

Great attentive service

Maria R., Dec, 29 2022

Quick, professional service

Doug N., Dec, 27 2022

Mike was very professional and gave me a great quote

Catherine N., Dec, 27 2022

Mike was very professional and gave me a great quote

Julia G., Dec, 20 2022

Mike took the time to get to know me and my needs. He answered all of my questions, which is particularly important to me as a first time home owner. The process was quick and easy. I would refer family and friends to him and his team any day!

Elizabeth D., Dec, 19 2022

Mike was professional, understanding and patient throughout the whole process. He walked me through each part of my quote and ensured that I understood. I would highly recommend working with Mike to others.

Rostyslav S., Dec, 18 2022

Mike was very helpful, knowledgeable and extremely nice. Being that this is my first home purchase, I had a ton of questions, which Mike was able to address, and follow up on. He was very flexible with time and responded even at evening hours. I would highly recommend using Mike for home insurance related quotes.

Maria M., Dec, 15 2022

Mike McGuire made the process very easy and was the main reason I switched to Goosehead

Anita H., Nov, 30 2022

Good service

William C., Nov, 22 2022

Mike Maguire is one of the best insurance agents I ever worked with setting up policies. Thanks Mike!

Raymond L., Nov, 15 2022

Mike made it very easy for me to switch my insurance and the rates were very competitive. Mike is very easy to work with and really seems to be out for your best interest. He is efficient and friendly, great positive attitude. Highly recommend!

William D., Nov, 12 2022

Very nice

Alvin G., Nov, 10 2022

Have been please with the service thus far.

Samuel B., Nov, 09 2022

Mike is very cool, extremely helpful. I don't talk about insurance with my friends usually

Thomas R., Nov, 01 2022

prompt and courteous answered all my questions

Brenda B., Oct, 06 2022

Was very helpful and explained everything

< Previous | Next >

Mike Maguire

Notice of Rights to Opt Out of Sale/Sharing

The Digital Agent is under maintenance